Kulvir Singh v. Union of India & Anr. LANDMARK JUDGMENT ON POLITICAL ASYLUM
2014 SCC OnLine Del 7206, decided 17 December 2014, W.P.(C) 4574/2014, with connected W.P.(C) 5480/2014 and W.P.(C) 7109/2014. Justice Vibhu Bakhru. Rajiv Gupta Advocate appeared for the petitioners in W.P.(C) 4574/2014 (Kulvir Singh) and W.P.(C) 5480/2014 (Inderdeep Chumber). The Court set aside passport restrictions imposed because the petitioners had sought political asylum abroad, holding that the asylum applications alone did not establish likely activity prejudicial to India’s sovereignty and integrity.
OKECHUKWU FRANCIS CHIBUIKE VS. UNION OF INDIA & ANR. W.P.(C) 5353/2025 is the Writ Petition where Rajiv Gupta Advocate represented the Petitioner as his OCI was being considerably delayed. During pendency of the writ petition itself, he got his OCI card.
FIRDAUS KAUSER VS. UNION OF INDIA W.P.(C) 1678/2016 was yet another Writ Petition in Delhi High Court where Rajiv Gupta Advocate represented the Petitioner and the relief of passport was granted to her based upon above judgment of Kulvir Singh. It was another Political Asylum case.
Apart from this, there are were multiple writ petition filed by Rajiv Gupta Advocate and relief of passport in political asylum cases was granted by the court.
Now there are appeals and writ petitions pending regarding the revocation of passport in the cases where the Petitioners reissued their Indian Passport after getting their foreign citizenship. Thus their passport was revoked and surrender certificate was not issued. Because of this reason, they are not able to apply for the OCI card. The outcome is awaited.
OCI: Union of India v. Bahareh Bakshi, 2024 INSC 646 — considered whether an estranged Indian spouse’s presence is required when a foreign spouse applies for OCI registration. Supreme Court judgment
Citizenship and NRC: In Re: Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, 1955, 2024 INSC 789 — examined the constitutional validity of Section 6A and the Assam Accord framework. Supreme Court case record
Citizenship by descent: Union of India v. Pranav Srinivasan, 2024 INSC 792 — considered citizenship claims involving birth abroad and the Citizenship Act. Case details
Foreigners and fundamental rights: National Human Rights Commission v. State of Arunachal Pradesh, (1996) 1 SCC 742; AIR 1996 SC 1234 — affirmed protection of life and liberty for Chakmas and directed action against threats and forcible eviction. Supreme Court judgment
Cross-border child custody: Surya Vadanan v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2015) 5 SCC 450 — addressed a habeas corpus petition involving children and custody proceedings in the UK. Supreme Court judgment
Cross-border child custody: Ruchi Majoo v. Sanjeev Majoo, (2011) 6 SCC 479 — considered Indian court jurisdiction and the welfare of a child in an international custody dispute. Judgment
Landmark Relief Before the Delhi High Court – Hina Ketan Thakrar Versus Union of India & Anr. Denial of Surrender Certificate by High Commission of India, London
A Significant Outcome in a Cross-Border Passport and Citizenship Matter
In a significant matter concerning passport revocation and the denial of a Surrender Certificate, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court, vide its judgment dated 3 November 2026, in Hina Ketan Thakrar v. Union of India & Anr., W.P.(C) 8475/2026, granted relief to the petitioner.
The petitioner, an Indian-origin British citizen residing in the United Kingdom, faced revocation of her Indian passport and refusal of a Surrender Certificate by the Indian authorities on allegations of suppression of material information regarding the acquisition of foreign citizenship.
Representing the petitioner, challenged the impugned orders before the Delhi High Court, placing particular emphasis on the bona fide circumstances surrounding the passport renewal, prior communications with the Indian authorities, absence of deliberate concealment and the principles governing fair and non-mechanical exercise of statutory powers.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amit Mahajan, after considering the facts and circumstances, observed that the statutory power to revoke a passport must be exercised fairly and upon proper consideration of the relevant material. The Court also noted that the omission could have been a bona fide error rather than a deliberate attempt to conceal foreign nationality or secure an undue benefit.
The Hon’ble High Court set aside the impugned order and directed the respondent authorities to forthwith issue the Surrender Certificate to the petitioner.
This matter highlights the importance of procedural fairness, proper appreciation of evidence and judicial scrutiny of administrative decisions in cross-border passport, citizenship and OCI-related matters.
Counsel for the Petitioner:
Mr. Rajiv Gupta, Advocate
Founder – KarVai Legal Solutions
New Delhi, India
Indian Advocate | Founder – KarVai Legal Solutions | AI Governance, Risk & FRIA Compliance | EU AI Act & GDPR | Cross-Border Litigation | International Arbitration | OCI & NRI Legal Advisory
I am an Indian Advocate with over 26 years of professional experience in litigation, legal advisory and regulatory compliance, and the Founder of KarVai Legal Solutions.
My practice focuses on providing strategic, practical and reliable legal assistance to NRIs, OCI cardholders, foreign nationals and international clients dealing with legal matters and regulatory challenges in India.
My key areas of practice and professional focus include:
– AI Governance, Risk Management & Compliance: Advisory on emerging AI regulatory frameworks, including the EU AI Act, GDPR, responsible AI practices and AI-related legal compliance.
– Cross-Border Legal Services: Legal advisory and representation for NRIs, OCI cardholders, foreign nationals and international clients.
– Private International Law: Legal issues involving cross-border transactions, jurisdiction, recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments, and international legal disputes.
– International Arbitration: Legal assistance in arbitration-related matters and cross-border dispute resolution.
– Immigration & Citizenship-Related Matters: OCI applications, surrender and renunciation of Indian citizenship, passport-related issues and other immigration-linked legal matters.
– Litigation & Regulatory Compliance: Representation and advisory before courts and relevant authorities in India.
Through KarVai Legal Solutions, my objective is to bridge the gap between international clients and the Indian legal system by offering accessible, transparent and professionally driven legal support.
With extensive courtroom experience and an expanding focus on international regulatory developments, particularly AI governance and data protection, I seek to bring together traditional legal expertise and the evolving demands of the global digital economy.
My professional philosophy is founded on three principles:
Integrity. Responsiveness. Practical Legal Solutions.
INDIAN CONTACT NO: +91 9811284735 EUROPEAN CONTACT NO: +49 177 6896939
EMAIL: LAWNRAJIV@GMAIL.COM
